The Case for Israel
The Case for Israel by Alan Dershowitz, JWiley & Sons - 2003 $20US
Introduction
Coming hot on the latest Israeli-Hezbollah/Iran/Syria warfare and now apparent ceasefire, Alan Dershowitz’s book has greater relevance because as seen in our essay on Disproportionate - as Desi Arnaz used to say to Our Love Lucie: “Lucie, you have got a lot of ’splainin’ to do”. Also Dershowitz already noted in the Introductory chapter of his book back in 2003 - “The Jewish Nation of Israel stands accused in the dock of international justice. The charges include being a criminal state, the prime violator of human rights, the mirror image of Nazism, and the most intransigent barrier to peace in the Middle East. Throughout the world, from the chambers of the United Nations to the campuses of universities, Israel is singled out for condemnation, divestment, boycott and demonization.”. And of course Alan was partially right then and will be painfully, self-immolatingly right now.
The problems facing Israel are twofold. Coming in the near future, is a set of dual risks. First is the risk of loss of public sympathy, especially in Western Europe and the United States. This loss of public support will come from two sources as well. Israel since the death of Rabin and the start of the Palestinian Intefadah uprising has increasingly departed from its military strategy that emphasized proportionate and precision (but overwhelming Israeli tactical advantage) with its military strikes. In addition, proportionlity was also maintained through deferred retaliation or immediate return-of-fire only when greviously provoked or openly attacked. The shift has been to knee-jerk Grapes-of-Wrath destruction in Gaza and the West Bank or American style “shock and awe” air-based military campaigns as seen in Lebanon at least twice. These retaliations for very real provocations have lacked the previous sense of Israeli precision and proportionate response.
Now Israeli strikes are more disproprtionate as seen in the number of Palestinian and Lebanese deaths since say 2001 and the sheer amount let alone dollar value of destruction of homes and infrastructure in both Palestine and Lebanon. Its this move to a “get tough policy” no matter what the provocation or the consequent collateral damage or disproportion of the response that will put off Western European and US populations. And these populations are actively aware of the hotbed that is Israel-Palestine/Arab dispute simply for the reason of the War on Terror. That War on Terror is not confined to Britain and America’s tribulations in Iraq nor European and American engagement in Afghanistan. It is blowing up in Spanish, English, and French faces too.
So the second reason Israel will lose critical support in the West is active and sizable Muslim populations in England, France, Spain, Holland and other countries taking out their wrath for various perceived and actual local economic and social disadvantages. But also these Muslim activists constantly return to the lightning rod that ignites Arabs, Muslims, and Palestinians in particular. That belief and grievance is that Arabs have always gotten a raw deal from the West with its almost unconditional, almost knee-jerk an, until the late 1980’s, disproportionate military, economic and social support for Israel.
But the fly in the ointment is now “just good enough” rocket science and a delivery vehicle in the form of a group that has just gained widespread Arab Shia popular support and begrudging Sunni Arab admiration - Hezbollah. As George Will pointed out on ABCTV’s Sunday News Report, on the last day of the conflict with Israeli troops swarming over most of Southern Lebanon, Hezbollah were able to launch 264 rockets on Israel, 30% more than on any other day in the war with Israel.
Now just take this situation down the road a year or two of continued unsuccessful wrangling over a Hamas-led Palestine and constant skirmishes between Hezbollah and Israelis plus US “leadership” with George W. Bush. The rocket science will improve. The warheads next time could be more sinister. Tell me now, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, what is a proportionate (leave alone disproportionate) response when Hezbollah or some other proxy Arab mischief maker lobs 2-5 missiles/day onto TelAviv and/or Jerusalem with not 3 soldiers taken hostage - but a whole nation ? Thus, the second problem facing Israel is that time and even “just good enough” rocket science are not on their side. And I am not yet talking about asymmetrical conflicts and a fractured Muslim community barely at peace within let alone able to police or govern itself and its various “distinctive” groups.
So as Macbeth would say - lay on MacDershowitz. Let me tell you that the one thing the US does not support for any long period of time is a loser - or a perceived can’t-possibly-win-but-have-not-yet-lost loser.
An Aside
Now a quick aside, Shakespearean in style. At this point of writing I have read parts of Alan’s book. It is tough going, like reading a Bush pre-Iraq war policy paper - in short an info minefield. So let me summarize so far on what Alan has done. He produces a straw man defense of Israel. He takes and then easily defeats arguments on the extreme against Israel - a line up of “shooting fish in a barrel” arguments that are easily refuted with any fair examination of the facts. He will not take on the 3 key arguments against Israel - ignorance, disproportion, and false restitution.
Ignorance - is Jay Walking. In his Jay Walking segment, NBC Late Night entertainer Jay Leno takes delight in showing how dumb and uninformed Americans can be about their own history and geography let alone anything outside their borders. I would be willing to bet a Baker’s dozen bagels that if you took a poll of 10,000 Americans and asked them where Israel was, how big it was geographically, and how long Israel had existed continually as a Jewish state - more than 5000 would get the first two facts wrong and more than 8000 would get the last one wrong. The excellent book, One Palestine Complete by Haaretz correspondent Tomas Segev tells how Israel emerged in the last 120 years from hundreds of years where the Jewish population of “Palestine” was a 50 to 1 in the minority . The new Jewish state of Israel (there is still a substantial Arab/Muslim population within) is a creation of the twentieth century. Thus, the Origin of the Species of modern Israel is very much a part of the nature of the current conflict there. And not just American but broad Western ignorance of the facts surrounding the emergence of Israel leads to the notion - that as one woman told a discussion group, “you can’t just allow Israel to be eliminated - it is one of the longest standing continuous democracies in the world.”
Disproportion - again we return to that word. But the problem is that the World community in every official and/or condoning unofficial war-disengagement and susequent partitioning of Palestine have given or conceded a disproportionate amount of the land to Israelis despite the fact that in every instance they have been the minority in population often by ratios of 2 to 1 or greater. This is one of the major craws that sticks in the throats of Arab and Muslim dissidents and their mullahs calling for the destruction of Israel. And I have not mentioned the diaspora of Palestinian refugees from Israel.
False restitution is the fact that Jews and the Roma and homosexuals and other Nazi-declared impures suffered the Holocaust. Make no mistake, the victims were disproportionately Jewish - easily 9 to 1. Because the Allied airforces did not bomb Auschwitz and the other extermination camps, because many Western countries did not take on Jewish refugees before the war fully broke out and because after the discovery of the Final Solution, Germany and Hitler and any collaborators were not put on notice by the Allies that they would be tried for any extermination War Crimes; therefore Jews deserve restitution in form of a Jewish state. And a state that deserves to be disproportionately large to accomodate all the potential Jewish in-migration.
It is these moral and ethical dilemmas surrounding Israel that I had hoped Alan would address. But this book is a microcosm of our 21st political undoing - the inability of world thought and political leaders to face truthfully let alone tackle some of the wicked problems fast accumulating in the economic, social, and political landscape.
The Actual Review
Still to be continued….
Permalink Comments off
Toronto’s Reference Library is at the core of the city - right above the Bloor-Yonge subway lines right at Yonge Street’s entrance to Rosedale and the Upper suburbs. It is also an architectural beauty both externally and internally - getting constant visitors snapping away at the curves and lines both inside and out.
A New Green History of The World by Clive Ponting - Penguin Books June 2007, $19US